A wholesome story from New Jersey shows what can happen when employees and shoppers drop their roles and act like people. It all started when Jeff Greene of Wayne, New Jersey, was checking out the deserts at his local Trader Joe’s with his family on July 6.
During his search, he asked an employee named Tara if the Key lime pie was any good. “Tara, who was putting out other desserts said it was her favorite dessert in Trader Joe’s, and I said, ‘Well, I make a pretty good one, too. But let’s try this one,’” he said in a viral TikTok video.
Jeff took Tara’s advice and put the pie in his shopping cart. But when he went to check out, Tara intervened. “She handed me a box of key lime pie with a receipt taped to the top,” he told People. “She had bought me a key lime pie herself and took the one I was about to purchase out of my cart. It was such a lovely and unexpected gesture.”
A week later, Jeff decided to repay the kind gesture. “My wife and I were kind of just hanging out, and I said, ‘You know what? Let’s make the pie,’” Jeff told Today.com.
@sophiegreene__ Some wholesome sunday content & pie. We love @Trader Joe’s @trader joes & Tara !! #wholesomemoments #traderjoesmusthaves #dadsbelike #parentsbelike
In the video, Jeff’s son filmed him driving to Trader Joe’s to give his homemade pie to Tara. “Was such a nice surprise, it was so unexpected, so I decided that I was going to make my homemade Key lime pie and bring it to Tara and that’s what we’re doing,” Jeff said in the video. “If a stranger brought me a pie, not sure if I’d eat it, but here’s hoping Tara at least appreciates the gesture.”
When Jeff returned to Trader Joe’s with the pie, Tara was shocked. “Oh my God!” she said with a huge smile. “This made my day, you don’t even know.”
“Can I give you all a hug? You don’t know how much this made my day,” Tara said, while welling up with happy tears. “This was so nice of you to do.” Before he left the store, Jeff made sure she kept the pie frozen.
The heartfelt exchange struck a nerve with people on TikTok. “So special and to know people still care about people,” Tiffany wrote in the comments. “Tara is a gift to the world; you are a gift to this world, and I’m willing to bet that pie is also a gift to this world!” Jordan added.
Jeff thought giving Tara the pie was a great thing to do in a world with so much negative news. “I thought it could potentially be a really positive thing to do,” Jeff told Today. “Especially given everything going on in the world, a small act of kindness and humanity goes a long way.”
The funny thing is that the Greene family has yet to taste the original Key lime pie Tara gave them at Trader Joe’s. “We can’t really go back to Trader Joe’s until we’ve actually tried the pie that she bought us,” Jeff joked.